October 2026: The 700-Word Mystery

It’s time again for our 700-word short stories. This October, our theme is pumpkins. It’s autumn. Halloween is coming! Time for pumpkin spice this, pumpkin spice that. Pumpkin bread and pumpkin pie baking in the oven. Trick or treating, with kids dressed up as ghosts and ghouls, spacemen and monsters, fairy princesses and mighty princes.

Our stories this month have two very different takes on pumpkins. Janet imagines a ghostly scene in a backyard pumpkin patch. D. Z. looks at a cold case illustrated with a carved pumpkin.

Enjoy!

Cat Among the Pumpkins

Why was Rufus in the pumpkin patch? On a moonlit night before Halloween? With fierce glowing eyes?

After all, he was dead.

He was my sweet, mellow cat, with orange fur and golden eyes. But he was old and had cancer. I said goodbye to him last October, right before Halloween. I buried him in the backyard, marking the site with an engraved plaque.

The pumpkin patch was supposed to be in the garden, in the corner of my backyard. But the vines had gone rogue. They’d meandered out of the garden and headed across the lawn, tendrils reaching for Rufus’s plaque. I repositioned them. They didn’t stay put. It was as though they had minds of their own, telling them to break free from the more humdrum vegetables in the garden. By then, the vines were producing baby pumpkins that got bigger and turned bright orange.

Fine. Let them grow where they will. I didn’t want to disturb my crop. Once I’d harvested, I could pull up the vines.

Foliage soon encircled Rufus’s grave. Now I couldn’t even see the plaque, covered by vines and surrounded by pumpkins.

I saw Rufus, though.

I’ve always heard that when you lose a beloved pet, you’ll see them again from the corner of your eye. Right after Rufus died, I did see him, from time to time. When I glanced at that spot on the sofa where he liked to snooze, in my mind’s eye, I’d see him curled up on the pillows and think about how much I loved my big purring orange boy.

I miss you, big guy.

But I hadn’t imagined him for months. Until now.

Imagination. My mind playing tricks. That’s what I thought it was, at first. But I’d never had a pumpkin patch before. Certainly not one with my dearly departed cat sitting in the middle, eyes glowing in the moonlight.

It unnerved me. Especially the eyes.

It was a few days before Halloween and there was a full moon, the Hunter’s Moon, according to my calendar. I had baked pumpkin bread earlier that evening. As it cooled on the counter, I relaxed on the sofa, reading. Then I heard a noise outside. It came from the backyard.

I went to the kitchen and peered out the window. I didn’t see anything at first. Then it seemed as though the moon brightened, illuminating the pumpkin patch—and a pair of glowing eyes.

What was that? A raccoon after my pumpkins?

I flipped on the outside light and stepped out the back door, ready to shoo away the interloper. But the eyes didn’t move. I walked closer and saw Rufus—correction, his ghost—in the middle of the pumpkin patch. It looked as thought he was sitting on top of the plaque I’d placed in his honor.

I took another step and heard an unearthly yowl. Rufus leapt from the patch to the top of the largest pumpkin, his orange fur contrasting with the darker orange of the pumpkin. He circled, the way he used to do when he was getting settled on my lap. Then he tilted his head back and yowled again.

Another cat appeared, this one black, silhouetted against an orange pumpkin. A cat as white as a ghost slinked from the vines to take up a post on top of a pumpkin. Still more cats appeared—all with otherworldly glowing eyes. There were all sorts of tabbies, calicos, tortoiseshells, tuxedo cats in all sorts of patterns and color variations. They yowled and meowed and purred, moving through the vines, winding themselves around the big orange pumpkins.

I didn’t know whether to be frightened or bemused. The cats—or ghosts—were dancing among the pumpkins, singing in unholy harmony.

I stood still, as though rooted to the spot, watching the feline spirits prance and sway, twist and whirl, vocalizing all the while. Then the cats padded away, one by one, until there was only one—Rufus. He did a slow pirouette, then stood still as a statue, perched atop a pumpkin.

He meowed at me, the way he did when he was alive. Then he vanished.

I smiled. See you next year, big guy.


Pumpkin Head

Halloween. I was called away from handing out candy at 9:00. A big, orange autumn moon threw long shadows of bare branches across the grassy expanse of headstones. A carved pumpkin stood in for the boy’s head. His bag of treats rested on a family headstone; I searched them.

Billy Witchup’s mother identified him, certain the clothes were her towheaded boy’s, down to his shoes. The hospital didn’t have a footprint, and he’d never been to a dentist. So, his mother’s word stood.

I interviewed Billy’s friends, trick-or-treaters, and the whole small town.

Mr. Witchup hung posters around town demanding his son’s head be returned. Nothing. The next year, a pumpkin carved with Billy’s face appeared on the Witchup headstone, causing a flurry of anxiety. After that, it became a curiosity, the face aging each year as Billy’s might have.

The War came. Billy’s brother died on Omaha Beach. His sister joined the Army Nurse Corps and married an Englishman.

His parents died.

On the twentieth anniversary of his death, I scrambled the evidence, reordered it, and read it anew.

We fingerprinted the body that night and filed them. No point in sending them out; he was twelve. I tapped the card on my desk, then queried police statewide in case they weren’t his. No hits. Next, I expanded the search for boys’ heads found in a six-state radius over the last twenty years.

Two. I ran the details for both; one three states north seemed a possibility. Like me, the detective there didn’t like cold cases. His boy was Chris Kane; they thought he had hitchhiked out of town until his head turned up in a ditch two days before Billy’s body. By the boy’s age and size, he could have been Witchup.

Back home, I took a picture of this year’s pumpkin head and circulated it. A week later, I drove 300 miles to a small liberal arts college a state over to meet with the Dean of Students. The Dean looked up from papers strewn across his desk and slid me a fraternity’s group photograph. He’d circled the advisor’s face. “I recognized the pumpkin head photo in the newspaper the minute I saw it.

“Billy … William Witchup?”

“Dr. Jack Reilly. Good head. He teaches literature. Students love his classes. He lives at the fraternity, keeps a tight rein on those wily boys.”

I waited until classes ended before popping over to the frat. One of the boys pointed out Reilly’s rooms. I knocked.

Dr. Reilly, a scrappy-looking blond, answered.

“You’re dead,” slipped my lips the moment I saw him.

“I am not!”

I showed him my badge and the photo of the pumpkin head. He grinned. “It is a bit ghoulish.”

I grabbed the photo back. As nicely as I could, I asked for his fingerprints. He obliged. Of course they didn’t match the body’s.

“Twenty years ago Halloween?”

He shrugged. “I went out trick-or-treating. When I got back, my father was on a toot. Mom made me change clothes, led me out the back, took me to the bus station and handed me an address. Made me promise to stay away, telling me I was the product of one-night teen love. My real father added me to his brood.”

“Mr. Witchup?”

“Didn’t want me. Didn’t know I wasn’t his. And couldn’t afford me; it was the Depression. That’s about it.”

“Except for the headless body your mother identified as you. Can I meet your father?”

Reilly’s father was on the front porch of the farmhouse, dressed in coveralls and dirt, a pipe clenched in his teeth. I showed him my badge. He stood, tapped his pipe on the chair and closed one eye. “Boy’s body was lying in the graveyard. Millie changed its clothes. Added the pumpkin head. I always thought it was wrong, burying that boy with no head.” He gestured toward a field of ripe pumpkins. “Never told Jack, but I snuck a carved one over every year. No crime in carving pumpkins, is there?”

I raised my eyebrows.

We reunited Chris Kane’s head with his body. Whether it was his or not would have to wait on science, as would his killer.